Apparel Samples: How to Evaluate a Fashion Prototype from an Overseas Manufacturer

In this comprehensive guide, we are covering something every fashion entrepreneur and designer should be aware of: evaluating apparel samples. If you’ve been working in the fashion industry for some time, chances are you’ve dealt with overseas manufacturers and received samples that were not exactly what you expected. So, how do you evaluate whether you've received a quality garment and whether the manufacturer is someone you'd want to work with long-term?

This guide will help you develop a foolproof approach to sample evaluation, whether you're dealing with fabric, stitching, trims, or overall garment construction. So, let's get started!

1. Fabric Evaluation: Touch, Feel, and Consistency

One of the first things you'll notice when you receive your sample is the fabric, which is often a standard color like black, white, or gray. This is because the factory typically doesn’t have your custom-dyed fabric on hand at the sample stage. However, this doesn’t mean you should let your guard down! Here’s what to look for:

• Feel: Does the fabric feel like what you expected? For instance, if you specified a cotton plush fabric, but your sample feels overly slick or synthetic, something might be off.

• Wrinkle and Stretch: Does the fabric wrinkle too easily? Is it too stretchy, or not stretchy enough? You should be able to compare your sample's physical characteristics to your tech pack specifications.

• Weight: If you requested a heavyweight fabric and received something much lighter, that’s a red flag. Always check the weight of the fabric and its thickness. It should align with the product’s intended use (e.g., activewear, outerwear).

• Color Consistency: Is the fabric color even, or are there blotches and inconsistencies? This could indicate poor dyeing techniques. Also, check for differences between the main fabric and trims—if they’re both supposed to be black but they’re different shades, that’s an issue.

2. Stitching Quality: The Details Matter

Stitching can make or break the longevity and quality of a garment. Here’s how to assess it:

• Loose Threads: Run your finger along the hemline or seams to check for any loose threads. These can indicate poor finishing or low attention to detail.

• Hem Finishing: Examine how the edges are finished. A poorly finished hemline may have jagged edges or unfinished raw fabric visible—these are signs of low craftsmanship.

• Stitching Consistency: Look at the consistency of the stitching, especially in areas like the waistband. Poor stitching density (too few stitches per inch) can cause seams to weaken or tear easily.

A well-constructed garment will have at least 8–12 stitches per inch (SPI). This is a good indicator of durability, especially in high-stress areas like seams. Stretch the fabric both horizontally and vertically to ensure the stitching holds up under pressure.

3. Trims and Embellishments: How Well Are They Done?

The details matter! Whether it’s a zipper, drawstring, or print, they can make a huge difference in the quality of the final garment. Here’s what to check:

• Zippers: Are they from a reputable brand like YKK, or are they cheap alternatives? Give the zippers a few tugs to check for snagging or breakage.

• Drawstrings & Aglets: Are the drawstrings the right thickness and material? Check the aglets (the metal or plastic ends of drawstrings) and make sure they’re sturdy. A cheap plastic aglet that pulls apart easily can be a sign of low quality.

• Printing and Embroidery: Whether it’s heat transfer printing or embroidery, make sure the print is even and durable. Rub it gently and see if it starts to peel or fade. Additionally, ensure that the prints are placed according to the tech pack specifications—misaligned logos are a huge red flag.

• Trims: Check for any other details, like buttons, clasps, or patches. Are they securely attached? Are they the right material and finish as specified?

4. Fit and Sizing: Does It Match Your Tech Pack?

Fit is arguably one of the most crucial elements in evaluating a sample. Even if the fabric, stitching, and trims are perfect, a poorly fitting garment can make it a dealbreaker. Here's how to evaluate the fit:

• Measurements: Ensure the garment’s measurements align with what you requested in your tech pack. You should expect a fit tolerance of about +/- 0.5 inches for most garments. For waistbands, aim for a tolerance of 0.25 inches.

• Shape and Structure: Pay attention to how the garment fits across different body areas. For example, if you're working with leggings, check the crotch area, waistband, and leg opening to ensure they match your desired fit and shape.

5. Grainline and Fabric Direction: A Subtle but Crucial Detail

One of the more nuanced aspects of sample evaluation is understanding the grainline—the direction in which the fabric is woven. This is especially important in knitted fabrics, as the stretchability and durability of the garment depend on it.

• Fabric Grain: When inspecting your sample, check the grainline. The grainline should run vertically on the body and horizontally on the sleeves. Misaligned grainlines can cause issues with how the garment stretches and fits. This is something that’s often overlooked, but it’s crucial for the garment’s final performance.

6. Additional Tips for Evaluating Your Sample

• Washing Test: After checking the basic structure, give the sample a wash. Does the fabric shrink or distort? Does the print fade? If the garment doesn’t withstand washing or loses its shape quickly, that’s a red flag.

• Wear Test: If possible, wear the sample or have someone else wear it. How does it feel in motion? Does it stretch properly or feel restrictive?

Conclusion: Trust Your Instincts and Be Detailed

Evaluating an apparel sample is more than just looking at the aesthetic appeal. It’s about quality control, ensuring that everything from the fabric to the stitching to the fit matches your vision and expectations. If a sample fails to meet these standards, it’s essential to have a clear conversation with your manufacturer about revisions before moving forward with a full production run.

By following these steps, you’ll have a comprehensive approach to evaluating samples and be able to make informed decisions on whether a manufacturer is the right fit for your brand.

About FittDesign

At FittDesign, we specialize in designing and producing high-quality sportswear and activewear. With years of experience in the industry, our team is dedicated to creating innovative and functional garments that meet the needs of athletes and fitness enthusiasts alike.

Contact Us

Interested in learning more about how we can help you with your sportswear needs? Contact us today!